Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Subscribe
The Brief | Namibia's Leading Business & Financial News
  • Home
  • Companies
    • Finance
    • Agriculture
    • Technology
    • Property
    • Trade
    • Tourism
  • Business & Economy
  • E-PAPERreader
  • Mining & Energy
  • Opinions
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
  • Africa
No Result
View All Result
The Brief | Namibia's Leading Business & Financial News
  • Home
  • Companies
    • Finance
    • Agriculture
    • Technology
    • Property
    • Trade
    • Tourism
  • Business & Economy
  • E-PAPERreader
  • Mining & Energy
  • Opinions
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
  • Africa
No Result
View All Result
The Brief | Namibia's Leading Business & Financial News
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinions

The illusion of coexistence: Is Namibia’s human-wildlife conflict policy serving rural farmers?

by reporter
November 17, 2026
in Opinions
5
A A
Close-up portrait of a man in a black suit and white shirt with a black tie, set against a dark background. The image shows only the upper part of his face and shoulders.

By Dr. Tuhafeni DaSilva Hishitelwa, PhD

A few days ago, I was having a conversation with a close friend who had just returned from a week-long safari in Etosha National Park. He was absolutely captivated.

He spoke with immense enthusiasm about the park’s vibrant, newly revamped infrastructure, the beautifully maintained roads, and the sheer abundance of free-roaming wildlife.

He also spoke about the fees increase from April 1st, 2026, with almost 200%, including: International Adults (Non-SADC): N$280 per day (up from N$150), SADC Nationals: N$180 per day, Namibian Citizens: N$60 per day, and Children (Aged 9–15): N$140 per day for international and N$90 per day for SADC.

As an academic, my mind immediately gravitated toward the economics of it all. We pulled up the latest institutional figures and discovered a booming conservation enterprise: Each year, Etosha generates a staggering N$90 million, strictly from park entrance and conservation fees.

An additional N$20 million per year could be unlocked through new tourism concessions managed alongside neighbouring conservancies and the Hai//om San community.

But as our conversation deepened, the romantic veneer of the Namibian safari began to crack. We started asking ourselves a deeply unsettling question:

Where exactly does this money go? More importantly, why are the heavily affected farmers living on the borders of these parks left entirely unprotected?

The very animals that wealthy international tourists pay thousands of dollars to photograph inside Etosha are the exact same predators and megafauna that break through the park’s porous boundaries, destroying the lives of rural communal smallholders.

Namibia is frequently celebrated on the global stage for its pioneering community-based natural resource management (CBNRM) model.

By devolving wildlife management to local communal conservancies, the nation has successfully overseen the recovery of robust populations of free-roaming elephants, desert-adapted lions, and apex predators.

However, from an academic and socioeconomic perspective, this international conservation triumph masks a grim rural reality. The costs of protecting Namibia’s biodiversity are highly unequal, borne almost entirely by vulnerable smallholder farmers who live on the front lines of wildlife interface areas.

Namibia’s Human-Wildlife Conflict Policy gaps

A critical examination of the National Policy on Human-Wildlife Conflict Management reveals a fundamental, systemic deficit: Namibia does not have a statutory policy for the compensation of damages caused by wild animals.

Instead, the framework operates on a rhetoric of “shared responsibility” that purposefully protects the state from liability. The Ministry of Environment, Forestry and Tourism (MEFT) explicitly rejects the concept of “compensation,” favouring instead the concept of “offsetting” losses through the Human Wildlife Conflict Self-Reliance Scheme (HWCSRS).

As ministerial spokespersons have openly clarified, these payouts are merely meant to “assist” farmers, not to match the value of the damage or loss incurred. This distinction is a deliberate structural mechanism designed to absolve the state from covering the true economic destruction caused by state-protected wildlife.

The catastrophic consequences of this policy gap are starkly illustrated by a well-documented tragedy in the Kunene region, where communal farmer Immanual Gurirab of farm Leeukop lost 76 small livestock, comprising 66 goats and 10 sheep, to a pair of marauding lions in a single raid.

Under the state’s rigid self-reliance scheme, Gurirab was allocated a flat rate of just N$40,000 for his entire livelihood.

From an economic standpoint, this “offset” is an insult. Assuming these were standard commercial goats and sheep, at a modest commercial market rate of N$2,500 per head, the immediate valuation of the 76 animals (including previous losses) would stand at a minimum of N$190,000. This calculation represents the bare minimum baseline.

It entirely excludes the premium valuation if the animals were stud-grade or included expensive breeding rams—assets that are vital for long-term herd viability and cost significantly more. By forcing a farmer to absorb a massive financial deficit of over N$150,000, the policy acts as a mechanism of impoverishment.

Gurirab, who used his farming income to pay livestock herders and fund his three children’s university education, was effectively left bankrupted by the state’s protected predators.

This is not an isolated anomaly. Across the country, from Kunene to the Zambezi region, smallholders like Brendan Miliko are forced into the same impossible math.

Farmers lose productive, Bulls, pregnant cows and entire crop fields, receiving tokens that fail to account for the labor, input costs, and subsequent season-long food insecurity.

It is part of an escalating nation-wide trend where human-wildlife conflict clashes increase in frequency and intensity.

The price of Coexistence

Data from the Namibia Agricultural Union (NAU) and the Livestock Producers’ Organisation (LPO) underscores that livestock farmers lost more than N$14 million to the combined forces of theft, drought-related illnesses, and severe property damage or predation by problem animals.

Predation alone swallowed over N$5.6 million of that total. Yet, because this comprehensive analysis reflects only a fraction of the sector, the union warns that a vast majority of communal losses go completely unrecorded because farmers feel deeply discouraged that nothing is being done about their situation, driving reporting numbers down.

The policy failure is equally severe in crop-producing regions. In the Omusati region, farmers are reeling from “heartbreaking” elephant raids, leaving vulnerable households desperate for government help.

A single night of destruction by a herd of over 20 elephants can completely wipe out a two-hectare field. For families like that of Omusati farmer Andreas Shikongo, this represents the total loss of a bumper harvest that could have fed his household for an entire year.

When these agricultural lifelines are shattered, delayed compensation leaves farmers structurally vulnerable.

A recent parliamentary standing committee oversight report highlighted a bitter paradox: despite the fact that communities around conservancies in the Zambezi region earned a combined income of N$30 million through wildlife and tourism, local farmers feel completely abandoned as elephants ravage crops.

When crises are reported, the very conservancies collecting millions in wildlife revenue routinely delay responding, frequently citing a lack of transport.

This dynamic reveals a gaping moral and structural fracture: the state prioritises the preservation of the animal over the survival of the human.

The administrative burden of the self-reliance scheme alienates the very people it is supposed to assist. Farmers face rigid bureaucratic compliance requirements, such as proving they implemented expensive preventative measures (like wildlife-proof kraals) and filing verified reports within a tight 24-hour window.

If livestock is killed at night outside an enclosure, claims are frequently rejected under the policy’s strict “duty of care” clauses, which officials defend as preventing the reward of “poor management”.

This punitive approach ignores the systemic vulnerabilities of communal farmers, such as deep-set droughts and the prohibitive costs of fortification materials.

This dynamic creates a profound economic asymmetry. While the luxury tourism sector and the national economy generate substantial foreign currency from wildlife safaris and trophy hunting, the local communities who serve as the involuntary custodians of these animals receive negligible direct relief.

Macro-level conservation revenues concentrated at the conservancy or ministerial level do not effectively trickle down to heal the micro-level devastation of a household that has lost its entire livelihood to a single predator attack.

From an academic perspective, this brings forward a thought-provoking critique of Namibia’s modern conservation architecture: Has the state outsourced its conservation funding by tax-farming the poorest members of its population?

By using weak “offsets” instead of true market compensation, the government forces subsistence smallholders to subsidize the multi-million-dollar global tourism and trophy hunting industries with their crops and livestock. This builds a highly explosive landscape.

When a state tells a farmer that twenty elephants have a greater right to a grain field than a starving family, it actively breeds rural resentment. It forces us to ask an uncomfortable question:

Can we truly call a conservation model a “success” if its survival requires the economic suppression and forced sacrifices of its own citizens?

Practical Policy Interventions

To transition from a system of enforced toleration to genuine, sustainable coexistence, Namibia must reorient its policy toward comprehensive economic justice for its rural citizenry.

First, the state must abandon the flawed “offset” philosophy and transition toward a fully funded, market-indexed national insurance and compensation scheme.

Rather than relying entirely on the overstretched Game Products Trust Fund (GPTF), the government should introduce statutory conservation levies directly onto the N$90 million generated by luxury tourism and photographic safaris to sustainably fund direct, real-value payouts for verified agricultural destruction.

Lessons could be drawn from the successful Motor Vehicle Accident (MVA) Fund, which reliably caters for accident victims.

Second, the administrative process must be decentralized. Entrusting localised validation to traditional authorities and regional stakeholders, rather than requiring highly centralised ministerial signoffs would minimise delays and eliminate the rigid roadblocks that exclude vulnerable claimants.

Payouts must be swift to prevent households from falling into cycles of debt and retaliatory wildlife killings.

Finally, policy directives must pivot from retroactive, weak relief to proactive wealth creation. Farmers living in conflict hotspots should be legally integrated into the wildlife value chain as equity shareholders.

True coexistence cannot be achieved through a policy that treats rural farmers as acceptable collateral damage; it requires ensuring that those who bear the heaviest burdens of conservation are also the primary beneficiaries of its wealth.

Dr Tuhafeni DaSilva Hishitelwa is a renowned Strategist, Corporate Governance Expert, Farmer and a Researcher. He writes in his personal capacity. He can be reached on hishitelwat.dasilva@gmail.com.

author avatar
reporter
See Full Bio
Previous Post

Who gets backed? How gut feeling decisions are holding Namibian startups back

Next Post

MTC targets 180 network upgrades, 33 4G expansions in 2026

Must Read

Woman with long curly hair in a navy blazer stands in front of a wooden bookshelf lined with books and photos.
Opinions

Who gets backed? How gut feeling decisions are holding Namibian startups back

November 17, 2026
Professional headshot of a man in a light beige suit, blue shirt, and blue patterned tie, looking at the camera.
Opinions

Perspectives of a young professional

November 16, 2026
Impact Property Fund listing signals new depth for Namibia’s capital market
Opinions

Your bank pays dividends. Are you receiving them?

November 16, 2026
Front three-quarter view of a dark green Tiggo 8 Pro Max SUV driving on a highway.
Analysis

140 Chery vehicles in Namibia face recall over major safety concerns

November 13, 2026
Leader brand and institutional brand incongruence
Opinions

500 000 Jobs: How a country operates against that deliverable !

November 13, 2026
Smiling man in a gray pinstripe suit and white shirt, posing indoors with blinds in the background.
Opinions

Evidence before concrete: Fixing Windhoek’s transport problem

November 13, 2026
Load More

Related News

Govt requires N$181m to establish radiotherapy department at Oshakati

Govt requires N$181m to establish radiotherapy department at Oshakati

April 22, 2024
Namibia lifts avian flu control measures, battles cattle lung disease

Namibia lifts avian flu control measures, battles cattle lung disease

August 8, 2022
Aerial view of a city with a red-brick church at a roundabout center, surrounded by roads and palm trees.

CoW overwhelmed by Windhoek’s growing population

October 28, 2026

Browse by Category

  • Africa
  • Agriculture
  • Analysis
  • Business & Economy
  • Columnists
  • Companies
  • e-edition
  • Finance
  • Finance
  • Fisheries
  • Green Hydrogen
  • Health
  • Investing
  • Latest
  • Market
  • Mining & Energy
  • namibia
  • Namibia
  • News
  • Opinions
  • Property
  • Retail
  • Technology
  • Tourism
  • Trade
The Brief | Namibia's Leading Business & Financial News

The Brief is Namibia's leading daily business, finance and economic news publication.

CATEGORIES

  • Business & Economy
  • Companies
    • Agriculture
    • Finance
    • Fisheries
    • Health
    • Property
    • Retail
    • Technology
    • Tourism
    • Trade
  • e-edition
  • Finance
  • Green Hydrogen
  • Investing
  • Latest
  • Market
  • Mining & Energy
  • namibia
  • News
    • Africa
    • Namibia
  • Opinions
    • Analysis
    • Columnists

CONTACT US

Cell: +264814612969

Email: newsdesk@thebrief.com.na

© 2026 The Brief | All Rights Reserved. Namibian Business News, Current Affairs, Analysis and Commentary

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Companies
  • Mining & Energy
  • Business & Economy
  • Opinions
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
  • Africa

© 2026 The Brief | All Rights Reserved. Namibian Business News, Current Affairs, Analysis and Commentary

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.