Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Subscribe
The Brief | Namibia's Leading Business & Financial News
  • Home
  • Companies
    • Finance
    • Agriculture
    • Technology
    • Property
    • Trade
    • Tourism
  • Business & Economy
  • E-PAPERreader
  • Mining & Energy
  • Opinions
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
  • Africa
No Result
View All Result
The Brief | Namibia's Leading Business & Financial News
  • Home
  • Companies
    • Finance
    • Agriculture
    • Technology
    • Property
    • Trade
    • Tourism
  • Business & Economy
  • E-PAPERreader
  • Mining & Energy
  • Opinions
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
  • Africa
No Result
View All Result
The Brief | Namibia's Leading Business & Financial News
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinions

The interview panel can make or break your recruitment process

by reporter
October 28, 2026
in Opinions
8
A A
Portrait of a smiling professional woman in a black blazer and white shirt against a beige background.

By Lisa Matomola

Organisations spend a great deal of energy attracting candidates, advertising vacancies and shortlisting applicants. Far less attention goes to the people who make the final call: the interview panel. That is a mistake.

An excellent strategy and a strong pool of applicants can still be lost in an interview room that is poorly prepared, disorganised or biased.

Through my work in executive recruitment, I have learned that the quality of the panel shapes the quality of the appointment. A good process does not happen by accident. It takes preparation and sound judgement.

Know the weight of the decision

Appointing a Chief Executive Officer or Chief Financial Officer is not about filling a vacancy. It is about choosing someone who may steward substantial resources, lead hundreds of employees and shape culture for years.

The strongest panels understand this. They do not treat interviews as a chore. Before the first interview, they can answer one question: what kind of leader does this organisation need, not only today, but five years from now? Without that answer, panels default to qualifications and impressive career histories.

Prepare, because candidates do

Candidates usually arrive thoroughly prepared. It is only fair that the panel puts in the same effort.

A prepared panel knows the job description and assessment criteria. Members have read the applications, agreed on the competencies to be assessed and know what a strong, average and weak answer looks like.

For executive roles, I strongly advocate structured, competency-based and scenario-based interviews. Instead of asking a candidate to describe their leadership style, ask how they handled a high-performing but disruptive senior manager. That reveals judgement and maturity in a way a rehearsed answer cannot.

An unprepared panel does more than weaken the assessment. It says something about the organisation’s professionalism.

Efficiency is not rushing

An efficient panel is not one that finishes quickly. It is organised, consistent and respectful of everyone’s time. When a panel starts late, overruns, or leaves candidates waiting without a word, it creates an impression of disorganisation. Many senior candidates take leave, travel long distances and rearrange demanding schedules to be there. Respecting their time is part of respecting their professional standing. But efficiency must never come at the expense of fairness or thoroughness.

The panel is being interviewed too

Candidates are assessing the organisation too. They notice when panel members interrupt one another, contradict each other or seem unfamiliar with the role. From these small signals, they draw conclusions about leadership culture and governance.

A disorganised panel can lose an excellent candidate before an offer is made. The interview room is an extension of your employer brand.

Fairness means evidence, not impressions

Panel members must apply consistent criteria and separate evidence from personal impression. An impressive personality does not automatically mean effective leadership, and a less polished candidate may have exceptional strategic insight.

Members should score candidates independently before deliberating. This limits groupthink, where people drift towards the most dominant voice in the room.

Conflicts of interest must also be declared. In a small professional community like Namibia, panel members will often know candidates. Knowing someone is not automatically a conflict. But any relationship that could compromise, or reasonably appear to compromise, impartiality must be disclosed and assessed.

Probe, but do not interrogate

The most revealing moments in an executive interview come in the follow-up questions. A candidate describes an impressive transformation. A skilled panel asks: what was your specific contribution? What resistance did you meet? What would you do differently?

But panels must challenge without intimidating or embarrassing. An interview is not an interrogation. The purpose is not to prove that the panel knows more than the candidate. It is to establish whether the candidate can succeed in the role.

Get the composition and the deliberation right

Panel membership should not be decided by seniority or availability alone. Choose people whose expertise matches the role, then be clear about who does what. The chairperson manages the process and stops any one voice from dominating. The HR representative or facilitator safeguards consistency and documentation.

The interview does not end when the candidate leaves the room. That is when the most important stage begins. “I liked this candidate” or “I think they will fit in” is not enough. Members must link their views to specific evidence against the criteria. Disagreement is healthy when it is grounded in evidence. Ultimately, the panel must defend its recommendation with documented facts, not personal preference.

Why this matters

Even unsuccessful candidates should leave feeling treated with dignity. They may become future applicants, partners or advocates. Candidates may forget the questions they were asked, but they rarely forget how they were treated.

For organisations, a poor executive appointment is costly: low morale, leadership instability, reputational damage and the expense of starting again. A well-run process supports merit-based appointments and leaves a clear audit trail, which matters in publicly accountable environments. Interview panels belong within an organisation’s governance and risk framework, not in the administrative corner.

Train your panels

Seniority does not make someone a good interviewer. Panel members need to understand competency-based interviewing, unconscious bias, evidence-based scoring and how to document a decision. Having sat on several panels does not mean someone has mastered assessment. Interviewing is a professional skill, and like any other skill, it needs development.

A final reflection

We spend considerable time assessing whether candidates are ready for the job. Perhaps we should spend equal time asking whether our interview panels are ready to assess them. In the end, the quality of the people we appoint is shaped by the quality of the people making the decision.

Lisa Matomola is the Founder and Managing Consultant of HITO HR & Training Consultants and CEO of the Institute of People Management (IPM) of Namibia. She specialises in executive recruitment, HR consulting and organisational development.

author avatar
reporter
See Full Bio
Previous Post

Tribute to Madam Penehupifo Pohamba

Next Post

Keeping the grid in public hands: The case against privatising Namibia’s electricity transmission and distribution

Must Read

Close-up portrait of a man in a black suit and white shirt with a black tie, set against a dark background. The image shows only the upper part of his face and shoulders.
Opinions

The illusion of coexistence: Is Namibia’s human-wildlife conflict policy serving rural farmers?

November 17, 2026
Woman with long curly hair in a navy blazer stands in front of a wooden bookshelf lined with books and photos.
Opinions

Who gets backed? How gut feeling decisions are holding Namibian startups back

November 17, 2026
Professional headshot of a man in a light beige suit, blue shirt, and blue patterned tie, looking at the camera.
Opinions

Perspectives of a young professional

November 16, 2026
Impact Property Fund listing signals new depth for Namibia’s capital market
Opinions

Your bank pays dividends. Are you receiving them?

November 16, 2026
Front three-quarter view of a dark green Tiggo 8 Pro Max SUV driving on a highway.
Analysis

140 Chery vehicles in Namibia face recall over major safety concerns

November 13, 2026
Leader brand and institutional brand incongruence
Opinions

500 000 Jobs: How a country operates against that deliverable !

November 13, 2026
Load More

Related News

Challenges faced by livestock farmers during the rain

Challenges faced by livestock farmers during the rain

January 31, 2025
Bidvest Namibia acquires Oshakati Indongo Ford dealership

Bidvest Namibia acquires Oshakati Indongo Ford dealership

August 23, 2023
New CEO appointed at Oonani Investments Group (Pty) Ltd

New CEO appointed at Oonani Investments Group (Pty) Ltd

November 1, 2024

Browse by Category

  • Africa
  • Agriculture
  • Analysis
  • Business & Economy
  • Columnists
  • Companies
  • e-edition
  • Finance
  • Finance
  • Fisheries
  • Green Hydrogen
  • Health
  • Investing
  • Latest
  • Market
  • Mining & Energy
  • namibia
  • Namibia
  • News
  • Opinions
  • Property
  • Retail
  • Technology
  • Tourism
  • Trade
The Brief | Namibia's Leading Business & Financial News

The Brief is Namibia's leading daily business, finance and economic news publication.

CATEGORIES

  • Business & Economy
  • Companies
    • Agriculture
    • Finance
    • Fisheries
    • Health
    • Property
    • Retail
    • Technology
    • Tourism
    • Trade
  • e-edition
  • Finance
  • Green Hydrogen
  • Investing
  • Latest
  • Market
  • Mining & Energy
  • namibia
  • News
    • Africa
    • Namibia
  • Opinions
    • Analysis
    • Columnists

CONTACT US

Cell: +264814612969

Email: newsdesk@thebrief.com.na

© 2026 The Brief | All Rights Reserved. Namibian Business News, Current Affairs, Analysis and Commentary

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Companies
  • Mining & Energy
  • Business & Economy
  • Opinions
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
  • Africa

© 2026 The Brief | All Rights Reserved. Namibian Business News, Current Affairs, Analysis and Commentary

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.